A 2017 critique of a medical association submission to a federal e-cigarette inquiry
Source material undated · Agencies and guidance
Overview
In July 2017 the source criticised the Australian Medical Association's submission to a federal inquiry into e-cigarettes. It argued that the submission contained factual errors, left out important evidence and relied selectively on studies. It also noted that an overseas commentator had written a critical commentary. The points below are the source's position about the submission, which is not reproduced here.
International experience
The source said the submission raised concerns but did not mention major reviews from Public Health England, a Canadian university and a UK tobacco and alcohol research centre. It argued that Australia was out of step with comparable countries, noting that nicotine e-cigarettes were legal or being legalised in the United Kingdom, the United States, the European Union, Canada and New Zealand. It asked why Australia should be right and those countries wrong, a point it left as an argument.
Specific points disputed
- The submission cited 2013 smoking rates, while the source said 2016 data showed no significant fall between 2013 and 2016, which it presented as a reason to try new approaches.
- The submission said young e-cigarette users often progress to smoking. The source said regular vaping among young people with no smoking history is rare, and that youth smoking was falling where e-cigarettes were available.
- The source disputed a comparison between Canada and Australia, saying Canada had committed to regulating e-cigarettes as a separate class and had a bill moving through parliament.
- It disputed a statement that e-cigarette use had grown more slowly in Australia, citing survey data it said showed similar growth in Australia and the United Kingdom.
- It said a statement that Norway had banned e-cigarettes was misleading, because Norway had announced it would lift its ban.
Context and limits
The source concluded that the association had followed the status quo and national guidelines without testing them. This is a contested judgement, and the association's own reasoning is not set out here. The post dates from 2017, and policy, evidence and the positions of the bodies named have changed since then.
Based on a 2017 blog post.
Related summaries
- A journal critique of a national research council statement on e-cigarettes
- Senate estimates questioning on Australia's 2021 vaping regulations
- Criticism of a national research council's 2022 vaping guidance
- A critique of a joint health-group position statement on vaping