A 2024 review of the evidence on vaping by Australian young people and how it was framed
Source material dated May 2024 · Youth and uptake
Overview
Written in May 2024 while a federal vaping bill was before parliament, the source argued that much of the public case about youth vaping rested on alarm and that risks were overstated. It stated that young people should not vape, smoke or use drugs, and described its aim as reviewing the evidence on risks, benefits and ways to lower uptake. What follows reports its position and its cited figures. Health bodies and medical associations hold different views.
How common and how harmful
The source cited a 2022-23 national school survey of more than 10,000 students aged 12 to 17, which found 29.9 per cent had ever tried vaping, 15.7 per cent had vaped in the past month, 4.8 per cent vaped regularly and 3 per cent daily. It argued most youth vaping is experimental, and that regular use is concentrated among current or former smokers. It said serious harms had been very rare, that some young users report cough, and that it found no clear evidence of lasting respiratory symptoms. It also argued that nicotine is not a cause of cancer, heart disease or lung disease. The source added that long-term effects may exist but would likely be small in absolute terms.
Brain, dependence and comparison with other risks
The source said evidence of harm to the adolescent brain comes from animal studies with high doses and that extension to humans is speculative. On dependence, it cited Australian estimates of 3 to 5 per cent and said this was concentrated in current or past smokers. It argued that vaping is among the less risky behaviours of young people compared with alcohol, illicit drugs and smoking.
Gateway and displacement
The source repeated the argument that shared risk factors explain the link between vaping and smoking, and that smoking has fallen faster where vaping has grown. It cited a United States fall in high school vaping from 27.5 per cent in 2019 to 10 per cent four years later, and Australian past-week smoking of 2.1 per cent among 12 to 17 year olds.
Proposed regulation
The source argued that high youth use resulted from the prescription model and illicit supply. It proposed licensed retailers with age checks, penalties for sales to minors, plain packaging, restricted advertising and flavour names, online age verification and CCTV at point of sale.
Context and limits
The source also argued that net effects on young people could be positive. That is a contested judgement and is not a finding of the surveys cited. The figures come from different surveys with different definitions, and the post is advocacy and not a systematic review.
Based on a 2024 blog post reviewing youth vaping evidence.
Related summaries
- Questions about a gateway study on teenage vaping and later smoking
- Reading the 2022/23 national survey data on youth vaping in Australia
- Testing the claim of a new generation of nicotine dependence among Australian teens
- Is vaping a gateway to smoking? A 2023 summary of five strands of evidence