Testing the claim of a new generation of nicotine dependence among Australian teens
Source material dated September 2023 · Youth and uptake
Overview
In May 2023 the federal health minister of the time said vaping was creating a whole new generation of nicotine dependence, and gave this as a main reason for stronger controls. The source responded in September 2023 with a fact check. It argued that, on Australian data, the claim was not supported, and it called for the statement to be withdrawn. The source also argued that nicotine dependence in teenagers is of limited health significance.
The source's estimate
The source built a rough calculation from several Australian studies, combining three questions. First, how many teenagers aged 14 to 17 vape frequently? It cited one study reporting 3 per cent vaping on 20 to 30 days a month and another reporting 5.7 per cent vaping weekly or more, and averaged them to about 4.5 per cent while noting the definitions differ. Second, how many had not smoked before vaping? It cited figures of 54 and 65 per cent and used about 60 per cent. Third, how many used nicotine? It cited figures of 53 per cent and 58 per cent, adjusted for those unsure, and used about 62 per cent.
Multiplying these gave a rough figure of 1.7 per cent of non-smoking Australians aged 14 to 17 who vape nicotine often enough to carry a risk of dependence. The source excluded young smokers on the basis that their dependence existed before they began vaping.
Other points made
The source described the effects of dependence as short-term withdrawal and cravings, which could be a problem where smoking is not allowed, such as classrooms. It said nicotine itself carries little health risk and is not a cause of cancer or lung disease, and that vaping is a weaker source of dependence than smoking, citing several studies. It repeated its position that vaping diverts young people from smoking.
Context and limits
The estimate is a back-of-envelope calculation that averages figures from different surveys, age groups and definitions of frequent use, so it cannot be treated as a precise rate. It does not address occasional users or those who later start smoking. Other researchers have drawn different conclusions from similar data, and the source's health statements are its own position.
Based on a 2023 blog post presented as a fact check.
Related summaries
- Questions about a gateway study on teenage vaping and later smoking
- A 2024 review of the evidence on vaping by Australian young people and how it was framed
- Reading the 2022/23 national survey data on youth vaping in Australia
- Is vaping a gateway to smoking? A 2023 summary of five strands of evidence