Smoking trends and the case for wider access to nicotine alternatives
Source material dated January 2023 · International comparisons
Overview
A January 2023 opinion article argued that Australian smoking rates had stalled while declining more quickly in places that permit other nicotine products, including vapes, snus and heated tobacco. It accused no individual but argued that Australian policy was shaped more by ideology and interests than by evidence. This summary reports the article's claims as its own position, and the figures come from the source.
The comparison the source drew
The source reported that the adult smoking rate in Australia fell by about 1.7 per cent a year from 2013 despite plain packaging and very high cigarette prices, while rates in countries with access to alternatives fell two to three times as fast. It cited a modelling study estimating that Australia would miss its target of cutting adult smoking from 14 per cent to 5 per cent within eight years. It acknowledged that alternatives were only one contributor.
Examples cited
- United Kingdom and New Zealand. The source cited a government-commissioned English report and a 2022 Cochrane review, and reported a 33 per cent fall in adult smoking between 2021 and 2022 after New Zealand legalised vaping.
- Sweden and Norway. The source linked low smoking rates, 5.6 per cent in Sweden by its figure, to snus, a moist oral tobacco product that the source noted is banned in the European Union and effectively unavailable in Australia.
- Japan. The source reported that cigarette sales fell by 52 per cent after heated tobacco products arrived in 2015.
The policy position
The source said the health minister, the medicines regulator and a national preventive health strategy had signalled stricter vaping rules, that there was no plan to legalise snus or heated tobacco, and that Australian policy was failing. It called the evidence for safer products overwhelming.
What the source leaves open
The comparisons are between countries that differ in culture, tax, enforcement and survey method, so differences in smoking rates cannot be attributed to a single product. The article does not discuss health risks of snus or heated tobacco in detail, nor the arguments of those who judged the evidence uncertain. Government positions have since changed.
Based on a 2023 opinion article.
Related summaries
- Youth vaping rates across countries and what they mean for regulation
- New Zealand's falling smoking rates and the smokefree law repeal debate
- UK guidance for health professionals on vaping and quitting smoking
- Themes from a 2023 international nicotine policy conference