Parliamentary inquiry evidence on enforcement and a regulated vape market
Source material dated July 2024 · Enforcement and markets
Overview
This page summarises a 2024 article that reported evidence given to a Victorian parliamentary inquiry into vaping. The witness had earlier set up a tobacco enforcement team within the Australian Border Force. The article presented the evidence as support for a regulated retail market for vapes, similar to New Zealand's. The page describes what was said and does not endorse it.
Main points of the evidence
- Prohibition and adaptation. The witness said prohibition has not worked in the past, and that criminal groups change methods when enforcement increases, for example by moving online, storing stock in houses, or having customers collect goods.
- Retail regulation and tax. The witness favoured strict retail regulation with a sensible excise rate, and noted that New Zealand applies a value-added tax of 15 per cent, which the witness said was working well.
- Reversing the cause. The witness said the only way to remove the illegal trade was to reverse the policy that created it, and pointed to countries with different settings.
- Relative risk. The witness said he was not a medical expert, but from his reading of international material believed nicotine pouches and vapes were much less harmful than cigarettes, and that a switch from smoking would be a good community outcome.
- Demand for nicotine. The witness observed that many people use nicotine for enjoyment and find it hard to stop.
Context and limits
The witness stated he was not a medical expert, so the health remarks are a layperson's reading of other sources. The article included a video and an opening statement, neither reproduced here. Other witnesses to the inquiry, including health organisations, argued for stricter controls, and the inquiry's final conclusions are not covered by this summary.
Based on a 2024 article reporting inquiry evidence.
Related summaries
- How tobacco taxes and vape rules relate to illicit markets
- Criticism of a 2023 Queensland laboratory report on illicit vapes