Criticism of a national research council's 2022 vaping guidance
Source material dated June 2022 · Agencies and guidance
Overview
This page summarises a 2022 opinion article that disagreed with the position on vaping released that year by the NHMRC, Australia's medical research council. The source said the council's review gave too much weight to uncertain risks and too little to the comparison with smoking. It is one side of a dispute, and the council's own document should be read alongside it.
Points of disagreement
- Comparison with smoking. The source said the key question is how vaping risk compares with smoking risk, and that the review did not weigh it. It contrasted the number of chemicals the review mentioned in vapour with the much larger number in tobacco smoke.
- Lung illness and seizures. The source said an outbreak of lung injury in North America was linked to contaminated cannabis oils, not to nicotine vaping, and that it knew of no evidence for seizures from ordinary use.
- Poisoning and device fires. The source said nicotine poisoning cases were mostly mild and that deaths from either cause were very few worldwide.
- Gateway effect. The source argued that youth smoking fell faster in several countries after vaping spread, which it read as the reverse of a gateway pattern.
- Quitting. The source cited a review reporting that nicotine vaping outperformed nicotine replacement in trials, and said the council's advice to keep trying standard treatments had low success rates.
- Dual use. The source said use of both products is a transition stage for most users, citing United Kingdom and United States data.
- Long-term safety. The source cited a British estimate that vaping is far less harmful than smoking and argued that waiting for decades of data was unreasonable.
The predicted effect
The source expected the guidance to deter smokers from switching and to be cited by groups opposed to vaping.
What the source leaves open
The article also includes a transcript of a radio interview, in which a member of the council's expert committee gave a contrasting view. The council's stated reasons for its caution were not examined in detail by the source. Long-term health effects of vaping remain uncertain, and the figures cited are the source's selection.
Based on a 2022 opinion article with a radio interview transcript.
Related summaries
- A journal critique of a national research council statement on e-cigarettes
- Senate estimates questioning on Australia's 2021 vaping regulations
- A critique of a joint health-group position statement on vaping
- A 2017 critique of a medical association submission to a federal e-cigarette inquiry