A journal critique of a national research council statement on e-cigarettes
Source material dated February 2023 · Agencies and guidance
Overview
In February 2023 a group of eleven addiction researchers from Australia and several other countries published a critique in the journal Addiction. It targeted a statement on electronic cigarettes issued by the chief executive of Australia's national health and medical research council. The original article summarises the critique, which called the statement scientifically flawed and unsuitable as a guide to policy.
Main objections
The source groups the criticisms by topic.
- Safety. It argued the statement stressed chemicals in vapour without saying that many appear at low or trace levels, overstated long-term worries, and wrongly tied nicotine vaping to seizures, EVALI and popcorn lung.
- Effectiveness. The statement said e-cigarettes were not shown to be cessation aids. The source cited a 2022 Cochrane review and a British research institute analysis as pointing the other way.
- Uptake of smoking. The source argued that the statement endorsed the gateway idea, while youth smoking data it cited showed faster declines as vaping rose.
- Population effect. It pointed to New Zealand, where it reported a 33 per cent fall in daily adult smoking in two years after vaping was legalised.
Precaution and bias
The critique said the statement misapplied the precautionary principle, because uncertainty about small long-term risks should be balanced against the known harms of delaying access for current smokers. It also raised concerns about the make-up of the council's working committee, noting that some members had published or publicly stated views against vaping. The source linked this to a separate complaint about the council's earlier report on another topic and called for a balanced review.
What the source leaves open
The council's own reasoning and any reply are not covered. Several of the critique's authors had a record of favouring wider access to vaping, and the source does not weigh that. Terms such as flawed and biased are the authors' judgments. Figures from other countries cannot be assumed to carry over to Australia without further study.
Based on a 2023 news summary of a journal critique.
Related summaries
- Senate estimates questioning on Australia's 2021 vaping regulations
- Criticism of a national research council's 2022 vaping guidance
- A critique of a joint health-group position statement on vaping
- A 2017 critique of a medical association submission to a federal e-cigarette inquiry