An open letter from academics on proposed vaping restrictions
Source material dated May 2023 · Politics and process
Overview
This page summarises a 2023 article reporting an open letter to the federal health minister of the time. The letter was signed by 44 experts in tobacco control and addiction from Australia and New Zealand, according to the source. It asked the minister to reconsider a proposal to tighten access to nicotine vaping products.
Outcomes the letter predicted
The signatories said they expected the tighter approach to have unintended effects. They forecast that illicit importers would keep supplying adults and young people, that smokers would find a lower-risk alternative harder to reach, and that some former smokers would go back to cigarettes. They doubted that doctors and consumers would take up the prescription route in large numbers, even after all doctors were permitted to prescribe. They also argued that an illicit market can only be displaced by a lawful, regulated supply.
The alternative they described
The letter favoured an adult consumer regulatory model, intended to keep products available to adult smokers while limiting access by young people. The source said similar models had support from health bodies in the United Kingdom and Canada. It also pointed to falling smoking rates in New Zealand and the United Kingdom, where vaping is easier to obtain.
Young people
The signatories agreed that protecting non-smoking youth matters. They argued, however, that harms from youth vaping were overstated, that frequent use by young people who never smoked was uncommon in the data they reviewed, and that vaping was more likely to divert young people from smoking than lead them to it. Those are the signatories' positions as reported, and other researchers read the same data differently.
Criticism of two government-commissioned reports
The letter also criticised a national health research council report and a university report, saying peer-reviewed critiques had found errors and bias in them. It concluded that the proposed policy would probably raise smoking rates and health-care costs.
What the source leaves open
The signatory list is omitted here. The letter states a collective view, and several health organisations took the opposite position. The two reports it criticised have their own defenders, and the published critiques are the place to weigh that dispute.
Based on a 2023 article about an open letter.
Related summaries
- A point-by-point reply to a state medical body's vaping statements
- The June 2024 Senate passage of the vaping bill and a joint media statement on its likely effects
- Evidence given to a New South Wales parliamentary inquiry on vaping
- Federal parliamentary debate on the 2024 vaping reform bill: themes noted by one commentator