Youth vaping advice from an Australian drug body compared with a UK health group
Source material dated September 2022 · Youth and uptake
Overview
The original post, published in September 2022, took a set of public statements about youth vaping from an Australian alcohol and drug foundation and placed each beside a matching statement from Action on Smoking and Health in the United Kingdom. The source argued that the two sets of advice differed on almost every point, and that the Australian material overstated risks. It also stated that vaping is not free of risk and that non-smoking young people ought to stay away from it.
Quitting and relative harm
On quitting, the Australian body said the evidence was not yet strong enough to back claims that vaping helps people cut down or stop smoking. The UK group described vaping as a useful quitting aid for adult smokers. On relative harm, the Australian body said replacing cigarettes might be less harmful but that this was not yet known for certain, while the UK group called vaping much less harmful than smoking. The source added that the majority of young vapers smoke now or did before, and that the risk from smoking is far greater.
Long-term effects and lung illness
The Australian body noted that the long-term effects of smoking took decades to understand and that firm conclusions about vaping need long-term research. The UK group accepted that the longer-term risks cannot be stated precisely but expected them to be substantially lower than for smoking. On the lung illness known as EVALI, the Australian statement pointed to a possible link between vaping and lung harm. The UK group said the 2019 outbreak in the United States was linked to cannabis products containing a vitamin E additive rather than to nicotine vaping, and the source agreed.
Nicotine, dependence and chemicals
The Australian body said nicotine in the teenage years can affect brain development and can lead to dependence. The source answered with a report from a UK medical college saying the evidence on brain effects comes from animal studies and that its relevance to humans is uncertain. The UK group was reported as saying that dependence among young people who try vaping is uncommon and appears to be lower than for smoking. On e-liquid contents, the Australian body listed chemicals that also appear in paint and cleaning products. The source cited a Public Health England review reporting that most smoke chemicals are at trace levels in vapour and that no clear evidence links particular flavourings to harm.
Context and limits
This is a summary of one commentary written to contest a particular advice document, so it presents one side of a disputed debate. The quoted statements were selected by the source, and the advice documents may have been revised since 2022. Readers wanting the full position of either organisation would need to consult those organisations directly.
Based on a 2022 blog post.
Related summaries
- Questions about a gateway study on teenage vaping and later smoking
- A 2024 review of the evidence on vaping by Australian young people and how it was framed
- Reading the 2022/23 national survey data on youth vaping in Australia
- Testing the claim of a new generation of nicotine dependence among Australian teens