Colin Mendelsohn ArchiveAustralian tobacco and vaping policy
Information archive. Not a health service or a shop: no bookings, quotes or dispatch.

Should e-cigarette use be banned in smokefree areas? A 2017 view

Source material undated · Regulation and law


Overview

This page summarises a 2017 blog post written when a state health minister in New South Wales was reported to be considering a ban on e-cigarette use in every indoor and outdoor smokefree area. The source opposed a blanket ban and favoured a more tailored policy. It is written in the past tense because the rules it discussed may have changed.

Arguments against a blanket ban

The source argued that banning use in public places could signal that e-cigarettes are as harmful as smoking, and that this might discourage smokers from switching. It said the risk to bystanders was small, quoting a British medical college report that described bystander harm from vapour as negligible.

On renormalisation, the source acknowledged the concern that visible vaping might make smoking-like behaviour look acceptable. It replied that it knew of no evidence of this, citing a public health agency in England that found no sign e-cigarettes were reversing the decline in smoking. It also cited an epidemiologist who said normalising vaping could be a good thing.

On young people, the source cited a Canadian university review that found no gateway effect, and said regular use among never-smokers was rare in studies from several countries, while most youth use was experimental and short.

The alternative proposed

The source proposed three tiers. Open-air spaces would allow vaping, since exposure is even lower outdoors. Indoors, businesses and local authorities would decide for their own premises, for example a pub could permit it in one area only. The source offered further detail for other settings that is not summarised here.

Context and limits

The post cites the evidence available in 2017, and later research on vapour exposure and youth use is not covered. Public health bodies have supported use restrictions for reasons including enforcement simplicity and the protection of children. The statements about risk are the source's quotations of other bodies and are not confirmed here.

Based on a 2017 blog post.

This page summarises published material for general information. It reports what a source argued, not the library's own finding, and it is not medical advice or a substitute for advice from a licensed health professional. Details of laws and programs may have changed since the source was written.

Related summaries